Perceptions on the Mistakes of Youth

Dilara Goshtaiy
Page Body

Roderick, A., Guo, Y., Robbins, P., & Campione-Barr, N. (2026). Adults’ perceptions of childhood transgressions: The role of parental status and knowledge of child development. Journal of Moral Education, 1–23. https://doi.org/10.1080/03057240.2026.2640983

How often did you feel misunderstood as a child growing up? Probably a lot. Unfortunately, misunderstanding is a common theme between adults and children that can cause a disconnect. In order to avoid this, adults require a greater understanding of why a child acts the way they do to act appropriately. In this research article, researchers define these misbehaviors as transgressions. This study explores adults’ perception on different transgressions children commit. The three transgressions included in this study are moral, conventional, and prudential transgressions. A moral transgression is an act that violates moral codes and ethical principles. Conventional transgressions are acts that violate social norms and social order. Finally, a prudential transgression is an act that harms oneself. This research finds that adults' perceptions change based on the type of transgression a child commits, the child’s age, how much knowledge the participant has on child development, and whether it’s a parent or non-parent judging the situation. This study highlights how important it is to have knowledge on child development in relation to the perception of transgressions or mistakes youth commit. 

The participants in this research study aged from 18 to 50 years old. About 50% were parents and the other 50% were nonparents. The majority of these participants were white women. The participants took an online survey that provided six different hypothetical situations covering different types of transgressions (moral, conventional, and prudential). They then were asked to rate how wrong and punishable these transgressions were. In addition, they also rated how well they believed a child at a given age group (older children were middle school age, younger children were preschool or kindergarten age) understands right from wrong. Researchers for this study also used the Knowledge of Child Development Inventory (KCDI) to determine how knowledgeable the participants were on child development. This would allow them to analyze how knowledge in child development influenced participant ratings.

This study found that participants judged moral transgressions as more wrong than other transgressions. Participants also viewed older children’s transgressions as more wrong and more punishable than younger children’s transgressions. Participants judged moral transgressions as more innate, or something that should just be understood to be wrong, as well. Nonparents judged older children as having a greater understanding than parents did. These findings were mostly expected by the researchers. However, what was contrary to the researchers’ hypotheses was that participants who were parents judged conventional and prudential transgressions as more wrong than nonparents. This may be because parents deal with everyday conventional and prudential transgressions more frequently than nonparents. These results fortified previously conducted research in this field. 

This study highlights the need of educating adults on child development and continuing research in this field to further understand the impacts that these perceptions have on children. This may be particularly influential in the areas of child welfare and juvenile court systems where adults without knowledge of what behaviors are appropriate at each stage may be overly harsh in their reactions and punishments of such behaviors.